Anxiety is a tricky beast. In what can feel like a heartbeat, it reduces the most flexible of us to rigid and reactive creatures. It can lead us from plasticity and adaptation to obstinate self-sabotage. And it can alienate those who would perhaps engage alongside us to mend the gap between threat response and adaptive function. I’m an increasingly firm believer that our primary role as providers in child mental health is best conceptualized as an alternative form of collaborative storytelling, a narrative that we co-write with our patients. This article is an attempt to distill years of mutual engagement alongside children and families coping with childhood anxiety and hopefully give you a framework to engage children with anxiety spectrum disorders in children and adolescents more successfully.
We start with a story I’ve told hundreds of times. Picture this… You are alongside two of your closest and most trusted friends on a jungle trek. Both the air and the foliage are thick, the company less so. The visibility is limited, and the trail is only wide enough for one person at a time. You are leading the pack. Suddenly, both of your friends notice you stop abruptly mid stride. Your neck and back muscles are visibly tense and both of your friends experience a rising awareness in their stomach and chest that something is terribly wrong. You turn around and whisper through clenched teeth, “tiger!!,” alerting them both to the immediate danger that you perceive crouched several yards down the jungle path. You have a very STRONG awareness of what is happening here and there are only two ways that this is going to play out in your mind. 1, the tiger immediately charges and the three of you are in for the fight of your lives or 2. The “herd” turns on their heels and flees in terror. In either scenario, the alert that your body and voice served up may just have saved the day! However, what happens next is stunning. Immediately, both of your friends look back at you with a mix of confusion and revulsion. “That’s not a real tiger!” one of them exclaims, sounding both annoyed and relieved at the same time. “Wow, way to freak us out! Maybe chill out a little bit and stop being so jumpy all the time dude,” says the other. Both roll their eyes at each other and scoff before saying to you, in unison (and in somewhat of a sing song, taunting fashion if we are honest…) “Get to the back of the line.”
Stay in this role for a bit. How do you feel? What do you think your reaction would be? Do you think that these two individuals would still feel like “trusted friends”? And remember, the tiger that you FEEL so strongly is still (in your frame of reference) crouched several yards down the path. If you can place yourself deeply into this story, I think that you may feel some betrayal, maybe some sadness, maybe even anger or rage at how quickly your warning was dismissed. This is the position that we place children in consistently when they present with struggles managing their threat response system (also known as the amygdala or the limbic system). Often, in the context of their home and school existence, they are consistently met with responses emphasizing how “sensitive/reactive” they are. People may accuse them of being “dramatic” or concern themselves with how often the child will “overplay/overreact” to stimuli either within the world or within interpersonal communication. When they come into treatment, we in child behavioral health often focus on their “cognitive distortions” or persist in labeling their internal threat response as pathologic. “NOT A REAL TIGER!,” we immediately yell, on repeat and from all sides, and then we walk away feeling we have done our part to build “insight.” Meanwhile the tiger is still there, and the child is moving further and further away.
But what if the tiger is truly made of styrofoam? Maybe your “friends” know something you don’t (and if so, what kind of a sadistic jerk put that incredibly authentic life-like styrofoam tiger there?). How could your companions let you know (in a way that you could hear and respond to!) that the menacing tiger ahead is not exactly what he seems?
I think there is a fundamental flaw in what is often our initial approach to anxiety in childhood. Think back to the initial verbal exchange in the story, the one you whispered when you were in full “tiger mode.” What was the purpose of this communication? First, take note that you’d already sent the communication back to your “friends” with your muscles, your head and your gaze. The tension and direction of your body told them all they needed to know, and they felt it, all the way down to their tingly toes. The transaction, both physical and verbal, had a very clear purpose, TO KEEP US SAFE. Children have this experience regularly. They rely intrinsically (as we will learn in even more depth in a bit) on limbic system activation to navigate a world of potential threats. Then, when the system is activated, there is an attempt to communicate to those around them (their tribe…) that a REAL threat has been detected and needs to be acted upon. “Shall we fight or shall we flee?” they ask with body and (at times) with words. If this response is initially demeaned, mocked, or ridiculed in any way (verbally or non-verbally), the lack of alignment is profound. In essence, the invalidation of anyone’s threat response moves us in the wrong direction therapeutically. Amazingly, the parental, teacher, or provider response of attempting to “redirect” or “treat” the anxiety is often at the root of the child feeling unheard and devalued. The resultant path can be one characterized by chronic lack of safety (both external and internal), low self-efficacy, and ongoing struggles to manage threat response within the child’s brain and body.
You may at this point be wondering, “But doc, if we say that it IS a real tiger (when it is OBVIOUSLY made of styrofoam!), aren’t we just enabling maladaptive responses and behaviors?” What a wonderful question you have just asked! I very much appreciate the participation!! This leads us directly to a discussion of the differences between validation and enabling. While these can initially seem to be difficult to tease apart, I think the difference can be quite easily understood. Validation is a conscious decision made within a human being to recognize the perceptions of another human being as valid and precious. It is a necessary step in being able to align with individuals with higher threat response and have your voice and concepts be heard and internalized. In fact, I’ve come to the belief (which you are likely beginning to surmise…) that validation (both external and internal!) is an essential part of most effective human change processes. Validation, however, is cultivated in the setting of emotional dysregulation. It is NOT the natural response, and we will learn more about this in a bit. Enabling is different altogether and is the more natural reflexive response. Enabling involves attaching to the distress of another human (in this case the child), experiencing your own nervous system dysregulation, and then responding behaviorally (in full alignment with the child’s dysregulation) to “get rid” of the distress. This response can take two major forms in childhood emotional distress. First, the adult may be swept up IN the “tiger response” and shift into fight or flight. The potential outcomes in this case are either aggressive discipline (fight) or primary avoidance (flight). Both responses clearly do very little to reduce childhood anxiety and threat response and often empower the threat response further. Second, the adult may be unable to tolerate the emotional reactivity of the child, but not fully attach to the “tiger response.” This leads to invalidation, and often to more dismissive or demeaning remarks as we’ve already discussed. This may make a lot of sense on paper as you are reading right now (hopefully you are currently in an at least somewhat regulated state), but it is devilishly hard NOT to do in practice (a fact that we should all remember when engaging with dysregulated parents…), To understand why it is so hard to separate from our collective threat response and behave differently in the moment, you need to meet my friend, Bill.
Bill (or William if you were from a neighboring tribe) was a paleolithic human. He existed alongside his close family and a few friends in the indelicate balance that was hunter gatherer society. The needs were clear, and the threats were real in Bill’s world. His small tribe of fellow homo sapiens were very close and profoundly connected. They were also extremely reactive and in tune with the world around them. In a very real sense, their nervous systems were connected to both each other and the world around them. (sometimes scenes from the movie Avatar play in my head when I ponder this). In terms of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, they spent most of their time at the base, physiological needs and safety needs. Their interpersonal acumen was somewhat limited, but they did have some wry humor. Bill’s mother often quipped that her father-in-law was “barely homo sapien” and there was a running family joke about his paternal uncle “going full Neanderthal” when he got into the fermented berries. There is one thing you need to know about Bill. His family called him “Chill Bill” because his amygdala was a bit underdeveloped. Bill was NOT, as I say to the children and adolescents that I partner with, “a big emotion brain human.” While in modern society, we may aspire to this “brain type”, in hunter gatherer society, it was more than slightly frowned upon. As Bill grew up, his tribe quite enjoyed being around him IN the cave. He was engaging, flexible and other humans’ distress tended to just bounce off him. As Bill grew, he began to be a part of the hunting and the gathering. These, as we’ve defined above, were the quintessential tasks of the tribe, and this is where the problems ensued. When OUT in the environment, Bill was not a very helpful member of the squad. He lacked a sense of urgency when responsible for meeting needs and seemed less connected to the threat response of his comrades. Within several weeks, he was demoted from hunter to “full time gatherer,” and the initial game of “rock, animal skin, super sharp rock” was played to see who would lose and have Bill on their gathering team. It was so bad at points that the rest of his tribe began to joke that it was good to be A (prefix anti or not) – BILL (this is where the terms able and ability come from…). They also began to be aware that when pressed, Bill would tend to tell half-truths or outright falsehoods to maintain the peace (“I swear I collected a whole other bucket of berries, it’s around here… somewhere…”) and would at times inexplicably be found reclining in the bushes during a very important gathering event. (hence the term Lie-A-Bill-ity). The point of this pun infested story is that for much of our evolutionary existence, the selective pressure was toward more reactive threat response. We continue to carry this neurobiological framework forward in our own nervous systems but often overlook or outright deny it (I’m looking at you, Renẻ Decartes…). Before Bill had even turned 14, he was out one day on gathering duty and was lounging in the bushes, enjoying a little “me time.” He had in his “air pods” (two smooth pebbles that muffled the outside world and amplified the music in his head). He was rocking out to “Eye of the Tiger”, eyes closed, nailing an air guitar solo. The bush moved to the left and Bill turned his head and opened his eyes. The song immediately became incredibly ironic, Bill would not procreate, and thus selective pressure once again pushed homo sapiens toward threat response as a primary operating system.
We can all learn a few things from Bill. First, there is a role for human nervous system regulation (I often call this “brain balance” when alongside children). Recall that when Bill was IN the cave, the strengths of his nervous system biology were adaptive. He was flexible, non-reactive and consistently able to modulate the distress of his fellow humans. These are qualities that we prize in our modern world and often correlate directly with individual success in family, academic or vocational settings. But, more importantly for this story, we can learn from Bill that human dysregulation also has a defined role. Let’s explore this in a bit more depth. Our central nervous system (CNS, ie, brain and spinal cord) is best understood as collaborative effort of different neuronal sub-systems. We are not one coherent whole; we are a sum of different parts. The parts and how they interact can be conceptually organized in many ways, but I prefer understanding them initially in the context of “rostral to caudal.” In CNS structure, rostral is higher in the brain (both superior and anterior) and caudal is lower in the brain (both inferior and posterior). General rules of thumb (for some reason these usually come in 3’s in biological systems, and this is known as the “Goldilocks Rule”) for moving more rostral in the brain are as follows:
- The brain is younger (in evolutionary terms),
- the brain is less important for life (think Phineas Gage…)
- The brain is responsible for “higher order” (or more flexible) tasks and cognitions.
There are corresponding rules of thumb for moving in a caudal direction in the brain:
- The brain is older (evolutionarily, I call it “tiger brain” for reasons that you are now familiar with, others may call it “lizard brain”, which is less compelling to me…)
- The brain is much more important for life
- The brain is responsible for more “concrete” (black and white) and reactive tasks.
So, we arrive at a bit of an impasse here. The rostral area where our higher order cognition and problem solving reside is at a profound disadvantage. It is non-essential and, in times of need, deprivation, or higher risk, easily sacrificed in favor of more concrete, reactive and essential circuitry (when was the last time that you were “hangry” and how flexible were you then?) This constant internal negotiation of our nervous system is often below conscious control and the stronger the threat response signal in terms of neural transmission (different from the REALITY of the threat!), the less conscious control is present. This is essential to understand when conceptualizing an adaptive response to another human experiencing a struggle to regulate their biological threat response (superior terminology compared with “anxiety” which often immediately comes with a pejorative connotation or suggests a “disorder”). In a very real sense, the activated individual is experiencing a “brain balance” crisis. Their world has narrowed, the threat is tangible, and they have very limited options to resolve the catastrophe. When I work with children in this regard, I resort again to animal metaphors. You can either “tiger out” (fight) or “turtle up” (flight). To expect someone to do anything else in the moment without a significant amount of validation, compassion and collaborative assistance (all focused on the development of insight, which we will discuss further soon) is to deny our own ancestry. It just ain’t smart.
Insight is a word that is thrown around quite often in therapy. For the purposes of our journey here, I will define it in a relatively simple fashion. I conceptualize insight as having two parts. First, it is a process by which we become aware of what is happening within our bodies and our thoughts. Specifically, we could call this becoming conscious of the inner workings of our mind and body. While on the surface, this may seem quite easy to some, it is one of the hardest tasks you could undertake. As the story of my friend Bill illustrates, to do so is to press back against eons of evolution to re-write a story that is baked into your DNA. Second, insight is the process by which we become aware that we are in more of a power position over our own threat response than we initially surmised! This takes time to cultivate, and the amount of time often correlates directly with the severity of the threat response. There is a method to this madness, and I often start at A-B-C. When becoming aware of the effect of your own internal dysregulation on your experiences and your responses (a key component in early anxiety therapeutic work regardless of age), I’ve found it helpful to start with a framework. My own construct is self-titled “The ABCs of emotion brain response” As we shift in an out of threat response/amygdala dominance daily (some of us much more often and more strongly than others, but ALL of us do this…) this mnemonic can assist in identification of states of dysregulation and hopefully over time allow for a pause before reacting (the beginnings of a process called “cognitive defusion”)
- A: ABOUT ME! – There is an ego centrism to threat response. Whether a literal or metaphorical tiger, the threat response activation triggers a profound sense of exposure and a resultant survival response. The NEED for safety and security is central and the world contracts. While often interacted with as selfish, myopic, or a deficiency in self-awareness, this is a pre-programmed aspect of threat response designed to keep us safe in the face of danger.
- B: BIG! – When the threat is detected (or better understood in some cases as “the threat detection system has fired”) The centrality of the threat cannot be overstated. Again, whether a literal or metaphorical tiger, the beast has become central and enormous in the threatened human’s consciousness. The hyper-focus on the threat is often viewed as maladaptive (“she just won’t redirect… she’s so stubborn!). But again, this is part of an ancient system of safety that is tried and true!
- C: CONCRETE! – This is the most fun of the ABC’s to explain to children and adolescents. I often will engage as follows: Say there is a tiger actively attacking you. Does it do you any good to begin to think “wait!, is this a nice tiger or a mean tiger? What are the characteristics of this situation that would indicate to me that this tiger is a threat? I should probably challenge my fear of this tiger because I feel overwhelmed and my tummy feels kind of icky right now!” These more flexible cognitions and responses have no place in the face of active threat! Again, the rigidity of threat response is often engaged with as a deficiency/problem that needs to be solved (“But Doc, he just gets so stuck and won’t even listen to reason!”). And as you’ve seen before, this is a fundamentally sound and necessary response to threat and needs to be treated as such.
Identifying the normality of our joint heritage of threat response does not encourage continued dependence on it. It is the first step in the journey of insight, and one that is often not taken, even in treatment. It is leapfrogged in favor of more tangible (perhaps not in the child’s frame of reference?) methods of developing insight that focus on challenging the maladaptive internal response and cognitions and placing external pressure on the child to shift their reasonings and responses. I am continuing to learn that a different approach, one that focuses on psychoeducation and safety as well as power (of the child) and partnership is key to allowing children and families to thrive alongside of their amygdalas (existing alongside and not in opposition to our threat response is a “no brainer,” because our “tiger brain” is not going anywhere!). The alternative is that they collectively continue to struggle against their threat response and then start pointing fingers at each other.
After all this mumbo-jumbo, we’re beginning to arrive at something actionable! If you’ve made it this far, I salute you! And perhaps I can begin to make it worth your while. I have three things to keep in mind when engaging with children who struggle to manage big “tiger response” and that come and see you for this very reason. There is (you guessed it!) a mnemonic for this. It is “CPS”, but this is very different type of child protective service.
- C – COLLABORATION: From the very first interaction, promote the idea and the practice of collaboration. If the person in front of you struggles with threat response regulation, collaboration will be very hard for them to feel. You are also pushing back likely against several other voices in their world (and in their own head!) that would suggest a non-collaborative scenario (some of these voices may have been yelling at them on the way TO the appointment and the “in the head voices” are likely pretty loud IN the appointment!) Heck, the fact that they are present in front of you, in an appointment with a psychiatrist made FOR them by their parents is SO not neutral! I would implore you to recognize that establishing collaboration needs to be an ACTIVE part of your role in the treatment relationship as the provider. If the relationship is defined initially by an exploration of their dysfunction and how we will categorize and fix it, you will inevitably be caught up in the threat response and defensive posturing and will likely find yourself beginning to experience oppositionality in the treatment relationship.
- P – PACING: You (the provider) are not in the driver’s seat! And if you are, your passengers will only be engaged and calm for a limited amount of time! Pacing is the process by which you adjust your response and communication to the physical and emotional tenor of the patient/family and treatment relationship. Think back to our discussion of validation earlier. It requires thoughtfulness, it is measured, and it requires both control and consistent responsivity and adjustment. Pacing is essential in the development of rapport and in treatment planning. If your interventions and your plan are made independently of the patient and family’s reactions, desires, awareness, and unspoken communications (think feeding a list of symptoms into ChatGPT…), then the output and the relationship lack both depth and flexibility. Depth and flexibility are necessary for sustainable treatment relationships and workable change negotiation alongside other human beings, especially if you are asking them to learn how to identify and respond more adaptively to their intuitive threat response system that has been the fundamental operating system of their existence since they entered the world. But no big deal, you got this! (Full disclosure, I feel like I “have this” less and less the more I do it)
- S – STAY HUMAN/POSITIVE: When all else fails (and it will, repeatedly), we have a collective space in which to regroup, but it needs to be nurtured and maintained. When you begin to feel the “rise of the resistance” in a treatment relationship, pause and take a breath (don’t think “what would Palpatine do,” but now you will think it… you’re welcome). You will notice very quickly that the rising tension in the relationship is transferred to YOUR nervous system as well. You will notice your speech quicken (pacing be damned!), your muscles tense (I feel it in my jaw, most palpably) and you, the HUMAN provider, will undergo a threat response metamorphosis. You will begin to view the patient and family as “other” (collaboration, it is not!) and you will begin to look for ways to extract from the difficulty in front of you (I’m looking at you, amygdala…) Recognition of this (insight!) allows you to then do something different. Be kind to you (your paleolithic hunter gatherer is showing and that is a-ok!) but also be kind to the family in front of you (the “treatment tribe”). This is the one time that you can “take the wheel” independently in treatment, but in a very specific way. You can respond differently to the distress. Slow your pace, explore the feelings surrounding what is happening in front of you, and validate the distress of all members of the tribe. My own way of doing this is that I end every hard session in a very specific way. In my head, I call it “full expression of positive countertransference.” (I didn’t use the term “mumbo-jumbo” at the beginning of this section for nothing!) I find something in the narrative and/or personhood of each person in the room that I resonate with, and that I find compelling and lovely. Mindfully and distinctly, I make sure to express that sentiment and all its positivity before we part ways. I’ve found this transaction (when done authentically) to defuse and warm even the most icy and stormy places.
If you can successfully implement this “CPS” in practice, I think you will find a wealth of opportunity in the difficulty of our collective work in child mental health. The flexibility (and resiliency, think burn out prevention) of your own practice will increase and the openness to collaboration (and subsequently, real human change) present in your patients and their family systems will grow. The most amazing outcome of enacting this approach is that you will begin to truly ADMIRE each of your patients. You will see them as they truly are: resilient, flexible, and dynamic human beings intrinsically deserving all the validation in the world. Then they, now seen and elevated, will engage anew with the power of their own neuroplasticity. The proof is in the pudding…
We’re coming to the end of this little journey and I’m hopeful you’ve had fun and learned a few things along the way. I’ll leave you with a framework that can be used to engage children, families, schools, summer camps, and basically all other places where human beings may become dysregulated and then rely on their inner threat response regulation system or their surroundings/trusted companions to balance their brain and body and re-regulate and engage. So, I guess this could be useful pretty much everywhere! The framework is “ICED,” a beautiful mnemonic that makes space for some cooling when the emotional temperature rises.
- I – IDENTIFY: At this point in our journey, you know the key components of identification in the context of emotional distress and threat response. It is a normal response of our brains and bodies to muster a reaction to perceived threat. It has been baked into our biology for eons (let’s have a moment of silence for Bill…), and we can begin to become aware of when we are flipping into an amygdala driven state (remember your ABC’s). This is not an “overnight” awareness and requires significant investment, time and consistency to build, especially in childhood. However, if all the main contributors to a child’s existence (parents, caregivers, teachers, administrators, etc) have some awareness of both the context and the goal of therapeutic work in childhood anxiety and emotional dysregulation, the insight can be continually strengthened and the uniformity of threat response challenged. If we all do it well, self-efficacy can be sustained and nurtured concurrently with emotional and behavioral progress.
- C – COMMUNICATE: A key piece of emerging self-regulation in severe anxiety and emotional distress is the ability to communicate and begin to use others in the “tribe” (family, classroom, social circle) for assistance. This is no easy task if your brain easily flips into full amygdala activation. I’m fond of saying this line to my kids and adolescents, “Emotion brain has no language center, but if it did, it would be populated by grunts, screams, 4-letter words, and music” The point of this exploration is to emphasize that language will fail you if you are in larger threat response. Those of us who serve as advocates for children who are “big amygdala humans” need to expect this and strategize accordingly. First, there can be a collaborative plan in place for limited language or a physical sign (hand or body gesture) that is used when the overwhelmingness is beginning to rise. It needs to be succinct and visible, and the child needs to trust that it will be consistently identified and acted upon. Second, we can reduce the verbal processing that happens during the dysregulation. Recall what we discussed earlier during our exploration of the provider threat response metamorphosis. Dysregulated amygdala has power and when we react without slowing our own nervous system, we may (often in a well-meaning way!) ask 4-5 questions in rapid succession to a child who has functionally lost their ability to speak (What’s wrong? How can I make it better? Have you used your coping strategies? Can you please use your words and tell me what is wrong?? Do you need to go the counselor’s office for a bit???). As we work effectively on more consistent identification of dysregulation and more fluid communication surrounding the emotional response, my experience is that the resiliency and participation of the child typically responds, but at their own pace. We as providers can frame and encourage that the pacing of response matches the child’s ability and development over time.
- E – EXTRICATE: If you have partnered together to begin to both identify and communicate more effectively surrounding times of emotional distress, the next response is to extricate from the loop of amygdala/limbic activation. Initially (and sometimes longer based on severity of dysregulation or younger age of the child), this often involves physical separation from the environment surrounding the experience of distress. Too often, children are cornered or trapped while they are actively in high threat response/panic. Far from de-escalating the situation, this is a “gasoline on the fire” approach. As in the communication section above, a defined plan is very useful. When the need is identified and communicated, a safe adult escorting the child collaboratively to a safe space is best. Over time and with further therapeutic work (and in certain cases medication management as well), the extrication from limbic dysregulation can occur inside the brain and nervous system of the child with less reliance on adult intervention and external change in environment. The support of this movement from insight to active emotional awareness and regulation is a core feature of the therapeutic process in the management of pediatric anxiety. As always, make sure the pacing of this plan matches the cognizance and responsivity of the child in front of you.
- D – DE-ESCALATE: Now that you have migrated successfully through the ICE, it is time to move on to the all-important task of de-escalation. You are probably quite aware of several of these techniques if you worked within the mental health field. The varied processes that we use to facilitate de-escalation of emotional dysregulation could fill several articles in and of themselves, but we will stay removed from this detail for now. I will submit a few pearls when thinking about using de-escalation techniques in childhood. First, take the child’s lead and maintain a sense of collaboration in de-escalation. Your thoughts and perceptions are much less impactful than your ability to elevate and empower the child’s internal thoughts and experiences shape them gently towards more adaptive responses. Second, move from the body upward to the brain. In childhood, anxiety is often experienced primarily within the body (think about the stomachache before school) and thus, de-escalation often starts with body awareness and body calming techniques. Over time (and with increased insight) cognitive techniques can be used to great effect alongside body calming (or grounding) techniques, but this should always be led and paced gently alongside the developing human.
I am so very hopeful that some of this was both understandable and helpful for those of you who are actively engaged in child mental health or considering a path of partnership therapeutically with children/adolescents and their families to treat anxiety and emotional regulation struggles. I continue to work actively daily attempting to hone the above techniques further. Often (pretty much all the time) this is directly in response to the engagement and feedback of the wonderful human beings I have the pleasure of partnering with in my clinic. With our common lineage identified and the knowledge that we walk the same path clarified, the sky (the one above the foliage…) is the limit in terms of what we can do together. So let’s raise a glass to Bill, make sure that everyone’s tiger is validated, and keep walking down the path together. And with each “styrofoam tiger” we approach in unison, the insight and flexibility increase, the therapeutic bond strengthens, and the path becomes just a little bit brighter.
